Welcome to AAB GLOBAL - Local - National - International Sign in | Help

RBA says banks not gouging Australians on variable rates

George Lekakis

June 19, 2009 12:00am

THE Reserve Bank yesterday backed claims by the major banks that they have not been gouging Australians on variable home loans.

The June issue of the RBA Bulletin contains a 14-page analysis of how the retail banks have been affected by the global financial crisis and concludes that the majors "have cut variable housing loan rates more than the fall in their cost of funds".

In the article the central bank confirms recent claims by CBA chief Ralph Norris and NAB boss Cameron Clyne that their funding costs were no longer tied only to movements in the RBA's official cash rate.

The central bank's analysis could have implications for Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and Treasurer Wayne Swan, who last week slammed the Commonwealth Bank for raising its variable mortgage rate outside of the RBA cycle.

Mr Rudd described the CBA move to up its rate by 0.1 per cent as "selfish", adding that it could inhibit the economic recovery. The effect of the CBA decision was to bring its variable rate into line with NAB at 5.74 per cent.

The Prime Minister's response fuelled public outrage against the CBA, which had become the fourth local bank since January last year to boost its variable mortgage rate independent of any official tightening of monetary policy.

However, the RBA analysis appears to validate Mr Norris's argument that the CBA home loan repricing was a genuine move to retrieve funding costs. "The recent financial market turbulence has increased banks' funding costs relative to the cash rate and this has been reflected in their lending rates," the RBA said.

"It is estimated that the major banks have reduced their variable housing lending rate by an average of 385 basis points since September. "This is less than the reduction in the cash rate of 425 basis points, but more than the reduction in their average funding costs of 330 basis points." The RBA research suggests that small business borrowers may have been subsidising the banks' generosity towards home borrowers.

On average the banks cut rates on business loans by only 230 basis points since the RBA began loosening monetary policy in September. "This decrease in the average lending rate across business loans is less than the decline in average funding costs," the RBA said. "Partly this is offsetting the fact that variable housing loan rates have fallen more than the cost of funds, but it also reflects some increase in risk margins."

All of the major banks have defended not passing on more rate cuts to business borrowers on the grounds that default rates on commercial loans have begun to increase in the past year. They say that the higher risk margins have been imposed to cover for bad debt blowouts.

In its publication the central bank hinted at the prospect of further mortgage rate movements outside of the official cycle. "For much of the past decade, banks' funding costs have tended to move in line with the cash rate, to a large extent reflecting stable conditions in financial markets," the RBA said.

"As a result, a market practice developed whereby variable rates on small business and household loans closely tracked the cash rate. This was not the case prior to this period, with banks lending rates being varied independently of the cash rate."
The RBA analysis found banks were now moving to preserve their net interest margins on lending after they touched record lows of around 2 per cent at the end of last year.

Commonwealth raises variable rate

AAP

June 12, 2009 12:38pm

COMMONWEALTH Bank of Australia will raise the interest rates on its home and business loans by 10 basis points to offset higher funding costs. The rate on its standard variable loans will rise to 5.74 per cent, from 5.64 per cent, from Monday June 15.

Interest rates on a range of its fixed home loans and its Residentially Secured Better Business Loan will also rise by 10 basis points from Monday. The increase in fixed rates does not affect existing customers. "This is a decision the bank has made reluctantly,'' CBA group executive of retail banking services Ross McEwan said.

CBA is the first major bank in Australia to lift interest rates on its mortgages since the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) commenced cutting the official cash rate in in September 2008. Since then, the RBA has cut the cash rate by 425 basis points to a current three per cent.
CBA head of retail products Michael Cant told AAP the bank was still the most competitive player in the market for home loans.

"Our rate is still the lowest of all major banks," he said. CBA cited increased wholesale funding costs and the cost of funding deposits as the reason for its interest rates decision. Treasurer Lyn Cobley said the bank raised between $31 billion and $32 billion in term funding in fiscal 2009 and will need to raise around $30 billion in fiscal 2010 to fund the expansion in its retail loan book.

The price of raising funds from offshore wholesale markets was still 12 times higher than it was prior to the credit crisis, she said. She said the price of raising funds in the domestic market was between 120 basis points and 130 basis points above the bank bill swap rate. "In the offshore markets depending on where you access them, they could be anywhere from 20 to 50 to 70 basis points more," she said.

 

Borrowers likely to be hit again

Author: Jacob Saulwick
Date: June 17, 2009
Publication:  Sydney Morning Herald

The Reserve Bank has signalled it is still more likely to cut interest rates than raise them this year, but mortgage borrowers could face higher costs regardless as banks drive rates up independently.

Interest rates have become a sensitive political issue, as the independent Senator Nick Xenophon called yesterday for tougher regulation to crack down on bank gouging, and business lobbies calling on the central bank to lower rates further to offset bank increases.

The public derision was sparked by the Commonwealth Bank's controversial 0.1 percentage point increase in its standard variable rate last week. Since then other banks have been increasing fixed mortgage costs because of higher borrowing costs in world markets.

From today St George Bank will increase its fixed mortgages by as much as 0.5 percentage points. The National Australia Bank has also raised fixed rates 0.4 percentage points this week.

The NAB's general manager of mortgages, Steven Shaw, said banks had been increasing their fixed rates for the past six weeks due to fluctuations in international markets.

He said fixed interest rates, which "directly reflect what the wholesale market is doing" had already risen about 1 percentage point in the past six weeks.

Senator Xenophon called on the Government to review its guarantee on bank funding, and impose limits on credit card interest rates and on the salaries of banks receiving government aid.

"Australians are sick of seeing a situation where we've been helping banks through a taxpayers' guarantee but they're lording it over us and living it up," he said.

In response, the Australian Bankers Association said Senator Xenophon had confused troubled US and British banks with Australia's, which had not had to receive direct government support.

The Government lambasted the Commonwealth's move, but Senator Xenophon said the Government should "stop talking the talk and start walking the walk" on bank regulation.

In minutes of its most recent board meeting, released yesterday, the Reserve Bank acknowledged concerns about the build-up of government debt across the world, but did not direct its comments to the rise in Australian government debt.

The minutes of the June meeting said the board did not see a "pressing case" for another interest rate cut. But members "viewed the inflation outlook as affording scope for some further easing of monetary policy, if that were to be needed to support demand at a later stage".

A report last week by the Commonwealth Bank said its funding costs would increase 0.42 percentage points by June 2010, suggesting more pressure on interest rates to rise. The Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry called on the Reserve to consider further cuts given the independent increases by banks.

 

 

Published Friday, June 19, 2009 12:50 PM by Branka Clay

Comment Notification

Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS

Comments

No Comments

Leave a Comment

(required)
required
(required)